Keurig Vs. Regular Coffee Maker (Drip): Which One’s Better?
How do you like brewing your coffee? Do you prefer the traditional drip coffee makers or the pod ones, like a Keurig? Coffee lovers are currently going gaga over Keurigs; they are quick, techy, and full of features. However, some people still prefer drip coffee makers to enjoy the most authentic and flavorful coffee.
So, are you someone scratching your head over the Keurig vs. drip coffee maker debate? Don’t worry; I’m here to the rescue. This post will cover all the features, pros, cons, and comparisons of both Keurig and drip coffee makers to see which one’s worth buying.
Now without making you wait any further, let’s dive right in!
Keurig Vs. Drip Coffee Maker: Our Verdict
Keurig coffee makers are best for people looking for glittery features and quick functionality. But if you want more authenticity and flavor in your coffee, regular drip coffee makers are the best and more affordable options!
Keurig Vs. Drip Coffee Maker: At A Glance
Drip Coffee Maker
4 to 4 minutes
60 to 90 seconds
No extra usability features
Very convenient to use
Extra additives like flavors and sweeteners
Keurig Coffee Maker: Overview
Keurig has been a well-known brand, manufacturing efficient single-serve coffee makers for years now. Keurig coffee makers use K-Cup and K-Carafe pods to brew espresso and other coffee beverages. Not only coffee, but the brand also produces tea pods compatible with its single-serve machines.
Keurig coffee makers are immensely popular because of their affordable price tags, convenient usability, incredible features, and high efficiency. All you have to do is fill the water reservoir, put in a K-Cup pod in the machine, select your cup size, and begin the brewing session. Your coffee will be ready in under 2 minutes.
However, keep in mind that most Keurigs are strictly for single-cup brewing sessions. So you won’t be able to brew a full pot of coffee. Also, you can’t put coffee grounds directly into Keurig machines–they only use pods. Though Keurig machines are convenient, the coffee quality of drip coffee makers is still better.
Convenient to use
Restricted to single cups only
Offers plenty of cup sizes
Expensive than regular coffee makers
Equipped with several features
Hard to maintain and clean
Keurig coffee makers can brew tea too
K-Cup pods are affordable and commonly available
Drip Coffee Maker: Overview
For drip coffee makers, we will take reference from one of the most well-known and reliable brands; Mr. Coffee. Mr. Coffee is the pioneer of coffee makers, and their drip coffee makers are truly the best creations of the brand. Mr. coffee drip makers work with ground coffee instead of pods.
Moreover, Mr. Coffee’s machines are not just restricted to single-cup brewing sessions; you can brew multiple cups at one time. Also, you will have to follow the traditional brewing methods while using Mr. Coffee drip coffee makers–pour water in the reservoir, add the filter and coffee grounds, choose your brew strength, and press start! These machines will then brew the most authentic coffees for you.
Drip coffee makers by the brand are much more affordable than Keurig machines. Since these drip coffee makers use coffee grounds instead of pods, you will be able to save some money there too. Though these machines require a little extra effort from your side to begin the brewing session, they are still quite easy to use.
Drip coffee makers can brew full pots of coffee
Takes longer to brew than Keurig machines
You can enjoy a variety of ground coffee flavors
Less convenience and features as compared to pod machines
Affordable than Keurig and other pod machines
Brews the most authentic and flavorful espresso
Keurig Vs. Drip Coffee Maker: Side-By-Side Comparison:
Now that you have gone through a brief overview of the Keurig and regular drip coffee makers, it’s time to dive deep into some technical details. Both types of machines have different specifications and functionality features. Therefore, it is essential to understand all the details to see which type is truly the best.
To give you a helping hand, we are sharing a detailed side-by-side comparison of Keurig and drip coffee makers below. Keep reading!
Design & Size
Design is the most important factor when it comes to buying coffee makers. After all, these appliances are going to sit on your kitchen counters, so how they look matters too.
Since Keurig coffee makers and single-serve machines, they are compact and lightweight. They can usually fit into the tightest of spaces. Also, they all have a basic build; a water tank, a capsule container, a drip tray, and two or more control buttons. Keurig coffee makers also come in a variety of color options to match every decorum.
While on the other hand, regular drip coffee makers are usually bulkier and larger in size, because of the large water tanks. However, you can still find some good-looking and aesthetically pleasing models. They also have a bigger space for the ground coffee and filter. Apart from that, you will get some control buttons too.
All in all, there isn’t a huge difference between the two types of coffee makers in terms of the design and size compartment.
What do you expect from a coffee maker? For me, it’s excellent coffee quality.
Keurig coffee makers do produce great-quality coffee. From espresso to lattes and cappuccinos, you can enjoy everything. However, the coffee quality is still not like regular drip coffee machines.
Pod machines like Keurig are quick; they brew coffee in a matter of seconds. Therefore, there isn’t much contact between the coffee grounds and the hot water. Eventually, the coffee will be good but not 100% authentic and flavorful.
While on the other hand, regular drip coffee machines give you full control over the brewing strength. They brew the coffee ground for a good amount of time with classic and traditional brewing methods. As a result, you get the most authentic, flavorful, and well-extracted coffee.
Keurig coffee makers are equipped with plenty of features to provide convenient usability. They have a one-button control system for the comfort of users. Some models have LCD touchscreens to add the cherry on top. Also, some Keurig coffee makers have automatic cleaning and descaling cycles. All you have to do is press a button or two and your coffee is ready. You may also find an auto shut-off feature too.
While on the other hand, regular drip coffee makers require a little extra effort from your side; grinding the coffee beans, tamping, and filtering. These models don’t usually come with extra features other than the auto shut-off one (in some models). Also, you will have to clean and descale drip coffee makers every month to clean the residue of coffee grounds.
In terms of convenience and usability, my vote goes to Keurig coffee makers!
Variety of Flavors
Both Keurig and drip coffee makers offer a variety of coffee flavor options. However, the options are more when it comes to drip coffee makers.
Since Keurig machines are only compatible with K-Cups, K-Carafes, K-Mugs, and third-party pods from brands like Starbucks and Lavazza, the flavor options are limited.
On the other hand, drip coffee makers use ground coffee. Now, you get a vast variety of flavors, roasts, and strengths in ground coffee. You can even combine and experiment with two or more flavors in a drip coffee maker.
As briefly mentioned above, Keurig coffee makers extract coffee from the pods for a minute during the brewing session. The coffee quality is great, but not the best. Though the brewing will be quick, the coffee won’t be very well-extracted.
On the other hand, drip coffee makers use the traditional method to brew coffee. They keep extracting coffee from the grounds for 4 to 5 minutes to give you a flavorful cup. You won’t be able to have a quick 60-second cup in the morning with drip coffee makers, but the coffee quality will be unmatchable.
Impact on Health
Drinking coffee has plenty of health benefits since it is enriched with nutrients and antioxidants.
Since Keurig coffee makers use flavored pods, there will be some extra calories, sweeteners, and additives in your coffee. Though this is not a major drawback, still a point of concern for some people.
Since drip coffee makers use fresh coffee grounds, you can rest assured that you will be drinking the most organic coffee with no extra calories and additives. It will only be antioxidants, nutrients, and health benefits.
Good quality and well-constructed Keurig pod coffee makers can last upto 5 to 6 years. Since most Keurig models are made of ABS plastic, they can break or wear out.
Regular drip coffee makers can last for as long as 10 if maintained and used well. Some high-quality and high-end drip machines can work for 15 years too.
I think it’s clear that Keurig coffee makers and more expensive than regular drip coffee makers, considering the extra features and functionality.
You can find Keurig coffee makers between the price range of $150 to $300. While a basic drip coffee maker is available for $30. High-end models can go to $200, but nothing more than that.
Cleaning and Maintenance
Keurig machines require descaling every 3 to 6 months. Apart from that, you will have to regularly clean the parts like the pod container and drip tray. Some Keurig machines also come with built-in descaling cycles; all you have to do is pour some descaling solution into the water tank and press the start button.
Drip coffee makers require daily cleaning apart from the monthly descaling to remove coffee grounds residue. Most drip machines don’t have built-in automatic cycles, so the cleaning and maintenance will be manual.
I think Keurig coffee makers are more convenient in terms of cleaning and maintenance.
Environmental impact is an important factor for some people when it comes to coffee makers. After all, protecting the environment is our responsibility.
Since Keurig machines use pods, they are not very environmentally friendly. People usually use the pods and dispose of them after the brewing session. However, you still have the option of using reusable pods with Keurig machines, but very few people opt for this.
On the other hand, drip coffee makers waste nothing–they are extremely environment-friendly. Your coffee grounds are going directly into the cup, leaving nothing behind.
How to Make Coffee With A Keurig Coffee Maker?
Here’s how you can conveniently make coffee in a Keurig coffee maker:
- Fill the water reservoir
- Open the lid of the capsule container and place your K-cup pod inside
- Close the lid and place your mug on the drip tray
- Select your cup size
- Press the brew button
Your coffee will be ready in 60 seconds!
How to Make Coffee With A Dprip Coffee Maker?
If you don’t know how to make coffee with a drip coffee maker, here’s a simple step-by-step guide:
- Grind your coffee according to the required size
- All drip coffee makers come with a filter basket–just place your coffee filter inside it
- Add the required amount of coffee ground inside the coffee filter
- Fill the water tank wait water
- Most drip coffee makers have a start button to begin the brewing session; just hit it
Your most authentic, flavorful, and well-extracted coffee will be ready in 4 to 5 minutes!
Keurig Vs. Drip Coffee Maker: Which One Is Worth The Investment?
Both Keurig and drip coffee makers have their fair share of pros and cons. However, which type to buy totally depends on your personal preferences and needs.
If you want to have a quick cup of coffee without putting extra effort into brewing, a Keurig machine is the ideal option for you. Keurig machines are also equipped with extra features and have compact designs.
But if you want your coffee well-extracted and flavorful, then the traditional drip coffee makers are what you need. They are more durable and the coffee quality is unmatchable. However, you will have to put some extra effort into the brewing session.
Can a drip coffee maker brew single servings of coffee?
Yes, you can brew single cups of coffee with drip coffee makers. Just add the water and coffee grounds accordingly.
Can a Keurig brew more than one cup of coffee at a time?
Only the Keurig machines compatible with K-carafes can brew more than one cup of coffee at a time.
Can a drip coffee maker produce specialty drinks as a Keurig can?
Yes, you can make specialty drinks like mochas, cappuccinos, and lattes in a drip coffee maker with frothed milk/milk frother.
What makes a Keurig so unique?
The extra usability features make Keurig machines more expensive and special.
What is the average lifespan of a Keurig?
The average lifespan of Keurig machines is 4 to 5 years.
Is it cheaper to use K-Cups or ground coffee?
Using ground coffee is more affordable than using K-Cups.
Does a Keurig use a lot of electricity?
A Keurig machine can use 200-400 watts of electricity in one brewing session.